Drafting Regulatory Preambles for Judicial Review

ACUS recommends best practices for explaining agencies’ statutory interpretations and regulatory choices as judicial review evolves.

The preamble that is attached to agencies’ proposed and final rules performs a number of important functions. The preamble explains the agency’s legal authority and the reasons for the policy choices reflected in the rule. When attached to a final rule, it also typically provides the agency’s response to significant public comments.

In supplying an agency’s explanation for a rule, the preamble provides valuable guidance to the regulated community and the public at large. Moreover, because courts generally judge the validity of agency policymaking based on the agency’s contemporaneous explanation, the preamble often plays a central role when a rule is later challenged in court.

At its June 11, 2026, plenary session, the Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) adopted a recommendation, “Best Practices for Drafting Regulatory Preambles in Light of Judicial Review,” which provides guidance to agency rule drafters with an eye toward preambles’ role in such litigation. Administrative law has been changing rapidly. Perhaps most notably, Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo ended Chevron deference—under which courts were required to defer to reasonable agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes—while leaving open numerous questions regarding how courts will approach statutory interpretation issues going forward. The U.S. Supreme Court continues apace in developing the major questions doctrine, which requires explicit congressional approval for agency actions of substantial economic and political consequence. Meanwhile, recent cases involving arbitrary-and-capricious review of agency policy decisions have continued to shape how agencies must approach formulating regulatory policy.

To begin, ACUS commissioned a report on drafting regulatory preambles in order to help agency rule drafters navigate recent developments in how courts review agency rules. The report, which was written by one of us, Deacon, and overseen for ACUS by the other, Nowacki, draws on a review of case law, academic commentary, recent preambles, as well as interviews with 19 current and former agency officials with experience within the new judicial review environment.

One of the report’s themes—which reflects the comments of many of the rule drafters who sat for interviews—is the need for agencies to double down on certain things that had always been best practices for drafting regulatory preambles. Those best practices include careful attention to statutory text, the consequences of the agency’s proposed or final rule, and possible alternative policy options.

That said, the report does describe certain ways in which agencies’ approaches to drafting regulatory preambles might change in response to recent developments. Post Loper Bright, agencies should provide what they believe to be the best interpretation of a statute they administer, even when the statute is ambiguous. An agency can no longer claim deference on the presumption that resolving statutory ambiguity is a kind of policymaking task. Many agencies had already begun to make this shift prior to Loper Bright. The formal demise of Chevron makes it imperative.

What is less clear is what kind of reasoning courts will consider persuasive when assessing whether an agency’s interpretation is the best one. In part for that reason, the report counsels that agencies consider remaining eclectic in the considerations they deploy in assessing statutory interpretation questions.

The statutory text is of paramount importance. But especially in situations where the text could support different conclusions, the case law suggests that courts will continue to draw on a broad range of factors, including a given interpretation’s fit within the broader statutory scheme, its tendency to frustrate or promote statutory purposes, and its workability.

Especially with respect to these more consequence-oriented determinations, the preamble provides the agency’s first and perhaps best place to provide a robust explanation that is tied to the record. Providing such an explanation can be helpful to a court in coming to its own understanding of a statute’s best meaning, whether or not the court expressly gives the agency’s views weight or finds that the agency is exercising delegated discretionary authority.

A separate throughline in the report involves using the preamble to develop the agency’s view of how past precedent supports its current approach. Identifying past agency actions that resemble the agency’s present position can be useful across a wide variety of domains, from standard interpretive questions to the major questions doctrine and arbitrary-and-capricious review. Of course, agencies may sometimes wish to break from past practice. The report thus covers considerations agencies may wish to discuss when they do.

The report discusses a number of other matters that can only briefly be mentioned here. Those include how agencies should articulate their view on whether a statute is best read to delegate the agency discretionary authority; how agencies should discuss the decisional criteria they used to reach the decision in question; how agencies should approach responding to significant comments; and how agencies should communicate how they considered any significant reliance interests when making a policy change.

ACUS Recommendation 2026-6 prescribes best practices for agencies to use when drafting preambles, focusing on two key aspects of the agency’s explanation: the agency’s interpretation of relevant statutes and the reasonableness of the rule being promulgated.

First, the recommendation encourages agencies to explain in the preamble to a proposed or final rule why the rule is consistent with the best interpretation of the relevant statute. The agency should also explain why that interpretation is consistent with past practice or, if the agency is departing from its prior interpretation, why the revised interpretation is the best interpretation.

Agencies should also identify the source of express or implied delegated discretionary authority. If a “major questions” issue arises during rule development or is raised in a comment, agencies should determine whether to address it, and if they do, explain why the rule does or does not raise a major questions concern.

Second, the recommendation suggests that agencies identify in preambles to proposed or final rules the reasoning for proposing or adopting the rule. This may include explaining the criteria considered in developing the rule and how the rule advances statutory objectives. Agencies should also address in the preambles any significant comments received and how they were considered, explain whether the agency considered any significant alternatives; and, if the rule represents a change in policy, explain why the new policy is justified.

ACUS has addressed other requirements of preambles in many other recommendations, including best practices for the use of plain language, drafting user-friendly summaries of complex preambles, the consideration of mass comments, and providing cost-benefit analyses. Recommendation 2026-6 builds on these earlier recommendations.

Daniel Deacon

Daniel Deacon is an assistant professor of law at the University of Michigan Law School.

Kazia Nowacki

Kazia Nowacki is the deputy research director at the Administrative Conference of the United States. 

The views expressed in this essay are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the Administrative Conference of the United States or the federal government.

This essay is part of a series titled, “Improving Federal Coordination and Accountability.”